About This Episide

The Story

An Unexpected Catch follows Bea Corinne, a pioneering woman who has carved out a career as an umpire in Chicago’s semiprofessional baseball league. With her sights set on leading the women’s athletic department at Western College, the last complication she needs is a romance with Emmett Worland, a talented pitcher with a questionable reputation.

But when Bea’s women’s baseball team desperately needs help, Emmett is the only one who can save them. As they work together, an undeniable attraction develops—complicated by Emmett’s painful secret that could end his baseball career and the undeserved bad reputation that haunts him.

What We Loved

The Undeserved Reputation Theme: One of the most compelling aspects of this novel is how Emmett’s reputation was destroyed through no real fault of his own. The sensationalist newspapers of the era seized on rumors and blew situations out of proportion, while his demanding, high-society grandmother gave him an ultimatum rather than seeking the truth. It’s a poignant reminder of how quickly reputations can be ruined and how difficult they are to rebuild.

Bea’s Character: Bea is a strong, determined woman navigating the incredibly narrow path available to women in her era. She knows what she wants professionally, but she also understands the precarious position she’s in. One wrong move, one perceived impropriety, could cost her everything she’s worked for. Her strength on the baseball field—holding her own even when challenged by angry players—makes her a memorable protagonist.

Historical Details: The book offers fascinating glimpses into baseball history, including the fact that umpires in that era stood behind the pitcher’s mound rather than behind home plate as they do today. These authentic period details add richness to the story.

The Heart of the Story

What really resonated with us was how the book explores the constant scrutiny both characters face. They can’t go to dinner together without people making assumptions. They can’t show too much concern for each other without accusations of favoritism flying. Everything tells a story—where you go, who you’re with, how you present yourself—and both Bea and Emmett must be constantly vigilant.

This theme reminded us of the timeless wisdom: people are always watching, whether we realize it or not. While the social pressures in the book may seem extreme to modern readers, they highlight an important truth about living with integrity and being mindful of how our actions appear to others.

The romance develops slowly and realistically against this backdrop. Both characters must learn to trust each other despite reputations, secrets, and societal pressure. The proposal scene was particularly memorable—a perfect culmination of their journey together.

Our Ratings

• Drama Level: Mocha—There’s constant tension from external pressures: Emmett’s grandmother, the press, university politics, and social expectations
• Suspense Level: Minimal—This is primarily a character-driven romance
• Mystery Level: Espresso—There’s some mystery around Emmett’s secret, though it’s revealed fairly early for readers
• Inspirational Level: Espresso to Mocha—The faith elements are woven throughout without being heavy-handed
• Romance Level: Espresso to Mocha—The love is there, but both characters are understandably cautious about showing it

Overall Rating: 2.5 to 3 lassos

This was actually our favorite in the series! If you enjoy historical romance with sports elements, strong heroines, and themes about reputation and redemption, An Unexpected Catch is definitely worth picking up.

Want to learn more about Abbey Downey and her books? Visit her website at https://abbeydowney.com/

Next week, we’ll be discussing the third and final book in the Adventurous Hearts series, An Uncharted Dream. See you then!